As a business, you always want to be growing your clientele base and gaining new customers. So how come customer retention delivers a better ROI than collecting new ones?
What is the difference between acquisition and retention, and which one should your business be using for sustainable growth?
Acquisition vs Retention
Customer acquisition is a process used to increase the number of new clients, and this can be achieved through marketing campaigns and lead generation.
For example, you may choose to invest in ads to help widen your reach or support your SEO to appear higher in search results. This increases the chances of potential clients finding your brand and following through with a purchase or enquiry.
Customer retention is focused on keeping current clients and preventing them from leaving to competitors. The purpose of retention is to build long-term relationships whilst increasing the customer lifetime value.
This is often achieved with follow-up marketing, such as emails or newsletters, remaining constant in the person’s mind. Alternatively, business have also been known to encourage repeat purchases through incentives like discount codes.
What Does Acquisition Really Cost?
The price of acquisition differs from business to business and is industry dependent but overall, it considers all the costs that contributed to the increase in customers.
A strong acquisition strategy includes targeting the right audience and using high-performing channels to improve conversions whilst controlling costs. These factors are what can influence the Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC). The calculation to work this out is:
CAC = Total Sales & Marketing Expenses ¸ Number of New Customers Acquired
But how do you know if your CAC is good?
To understand the quality of your acquisition cost, you need to compare it to your Customer Lifetime Value (CLV); a healthy CAC should be lower than the CLV.
If your CLV is lower than the acquisition cost then your business is spending more money on new clients than they spend with you, even if your revenue looks good, you will still be losing profit.
Tracking campaigns and having a data-led approach can provide insight into areas that may need adjustment and allow for the prioritisation of platforms that produce conversions.
What Does Loyalty Really Cost?
Loyal regular customers are reflected in the Customer Retention Cost (CRC). It measures the cost of keeping a client and stopping them from going to a competitor.
CRC = Total Retention Expenses ¸ Number of Customers Retained
Many businesses focus on customer loyalty as it is typically reflected that it is cheaper to retain clients than it is to acquire new ones.
Understanding the CRC contributes to understanding the amount that should be spent keeping regulars loyal. Similar to the CAC, the CRC should be lower than the CLV.
An alternative approach to calculating retention is the Repeat Purchase Rate (RPR).
RPR = (Number of Customers With Multiple Purchases ¸ Total Number of Unique Customers) x 100
This measures the percentage of purchasers who make a repeat purchase within a specified timeframe. A good RPR is around 20-30% as the higher the rate, the better customer satisfaction.
Keeping clients engaged can be done through multiple methods and some will prove more influential than others. It is important to continuously review each platform to understand the impact they are having on retaining clients.
Do Loyalty Programmes Actually Create Loyalty?
Loyalty programmes are a quite popular among businesses to help maintain their consumer devotion, but they are often just transactional convenience.
Rather than generating brand loyalty, they create interest in the programme so purchasers may come back for the rewards but can often be persuaded by competitors offers.
Personalised loyalty programmes can be more impactful; having offers that are meaningful to the client are often more engaging and suggest a value of being understood.
However, true brand loyalty is deeper than discounted purchases and rewards. It stems from an emotional connection with visitors over values and experiences with the brand.
This level of devotion is less likely to be influenced by competitor offers as it is based on an emotional level rather than transactional choice.
When Does Retention Become More Profitable Than Acquisition?
Every business needs both retention and acquisition but knowing which one to invest more into is important.
Keeping business can be more profitable than finding new clients, but this depends on the stage a business is at and can be influenced by multiple factors.
A startup or new business will find acquisition more profitable as there is a need to grow the client base and a reduced number of markets to retain.
Comparing this to a more mature business with a larger number of customers, this would be the point where maintaining customers is more beneficial than finding new ones.
Due to the increased costs that come with acquiring new clients, once a company has an established client base, retention typically becomes more profitable.
When Should Businesses Prioritise & Invest More in Acquisition & Retention?
There is not one single point that clarifies when you should switch your investment from acquisition to retention or when one will become more profitable than the other.
It can be influenced by many elements but having strategies for both makes it easier to switch between the two when required. There are multiple factors to consider when deciding to invest more in keeping consumers or finding more.
Customer churn rate is one component that can impact that decision. A high churn rate means there are more buyers leaving which could be due to customer dissatisfaction or for uncontrollable reasons. To reduce the churn rate, more investment into retaining people is required over acquisition.
Whereas a one-time purchase business will be focused on acquisition until a more loyal clientele base has been created.
Both retention and acquisition have their benefits. For short-term benefits, acquisition will bring more customers into the company but for long-term growth, retention can bring more value.